|
Principles of Resolution
In music, resolution is the dissipation of tension. A resolution creates a sense of relaxation or "letting go".
There are three principles of melodic resolution.
1st Principle: Resolution of a dissonance is always by step. The motion
to the note of resolution must be a smooth one.
Try comparing the these two resolutions, one ends with a rising resolution and the other
with a falling resolution.
2nd Principle: A falling motion produces a somewhat more satisfying
resolution that a rising one. Perhaps this is related psychologically to the relaxing of vocal muscles when
the voice descends. At any rate, a falling motion is more likely to be perceived as relaxing. Rising lines in
music tend to build tension, rather than releasing it.
3rd Principle: Notes which are a semitone away from a point of
resolution, are pulled towards that note much more strongly than notes which must move a whole step to
achieve resolution. When semitones are involved, the pull is stronger and the tension in the music is
greater. It's a bit like gravity or magnetism - as things get closer together they pull on each other more
strongly.
The effect of semitone is very strong and can easily overcome the tendency to fall, given in the
2nd principle. Compare the following examples, heard in the exercise you completed at the
start of this chapter:
The G-sharp in the first example pulls quite strongly back to the A, whereas the G-
natural in second does not. The second example could end quite satisfactorily on the F.
The G-sharp is pulled up because it is a semitone away from the A.
In the next examples the first ends with a D natural which could resolve up to E-flat or
down to C. There is a lot of tension in the D-flat of the second example. This note
pulls strongly to C because the C is only a semitone away.
Lines that descend a whole step often continue to fall, especially if the next step down is a semitone.
Compare these two examples.
In the first the G could go down a whole step to F, or rise back to A.
Both seem possible. In the second case, having the A-flat descend a semitone to G is
significantly more satisfying than returning to B-flat.
Compare the following lines.
In the first line the natural resolution of the D-sharp is back up a semitone to E, but in
second, after the whole step down to D it feels right to carry on descending, down to C which then pulls
you another semitone
down to B.
If a composer wants a line to go down and then return to the starting note a chromatic alteration is often
used, so that the step back up is a semitone. This is well illustrated in the following melodic line in E flat
major.
Note that the second note of each measure is chromatically altered, so that the following step up will be a
semitone. At the end of each measure a whole step down is used, and this leads the line down.
Listen to the same example in which the A natural has been replaced with an A flat and
the F sharp with F natural. Note how this changes the sense of flow in the line.
© 2005 Andrew Hodgson
|